Johnny Was is running multiple overlapping sale discounts, but the headline is the 25% Off Everything In Store. This applies broadly across fashion, jewellery, home and garden, and other categories with no code needed and no minimum spend. It is the safest choice for most shoppers, though targeted markdowns can beat it on specific items.
Buying a few pieces or shopping for a single item: The 25% off everything is your baseline. However, if you are after a specific product, check whether it sits in the 30% Off All New Markdowns range or qualifies for an even bigger individual discount. The Tank Sleep Dress, for example, carries 52% off, and the Camp Shirt and Italian Suede Crossbody Bucket Bag each offer 40% off. On a CA$100 Tank Sleep Dress, 52% off saves you CA$52, leaving you CA$48, versus 25% off which saves CA$25 and leaves you CA$75. The item level offers cannot be combined with other promotions, so verify the exact item before checkout.
Medium basket with mixed items from the sale collection: If you are buying several marked down pieces, start with 25% off everything. Then compare this against the 30% Off All New Markdowns if your items are newly reduced, and against the Up to 74% Off Additional Markdowns if you have pieces in that deeper markdown section. These three offers apply to different inventory pools within the sale. On a CA$150 basket of new markdowns, 30% off saves you CA$45 and leaves CA$105, while 25% off saves CA$37.50 and leaves CA$112.50. The 30% option wins here. If your CA$150 basket instead consists of additional markdowns at the up to 74% level, the savings could reach CA$111, leaving as little as CA$39, far ahead of both previous offers.
Shopping cosy robes or blankets: The 30% Off Cosy Robes applies only to that curated selection and cannot be stacked with other discounts. All Accessories From CA$44 and Blankets From CA$260 are fixed price entry points on sale items rather than percentage discounts, so they suit shoppers hunting specific categories at marked prices. Compare the final price of a robe under the 30% blanket robe discount against what 25% off everything would charge; whichever leaves the lower total is the answer. The same logic applies to blankets and accessories.
Choosing between your options: Line up the offers that apply to your actual basket items. Calculate the final price under 25% off everything, then under any targeted markdown offer that covers your pieces, and under any item level discount that might apply. Take whichever total is lowest. Remember that individual item discounts like the 52% off Tank Sleep Dress or 40% off Camp Shirt cannot be combined with other promotions, so use those alone, not alongside a wider sale discount.